Budget blues: Misery Index goes up


The Economic Survey released by the Finance Minister indicates that the misery index has increased.

The economy — GDP at factor cost at constant 2004-05 prices – has grown at five per cent in 2012-13 compared to 6.2 per cent in 2011-12 and it is forecast to grow at 6.1 per cent to 6.7 per cent in the coming year namely 2013-14.

There is a popular method adopted by economists sitting under the tall ceilings of Government buildings in Delhi to adopt what is called ‘ceilings method’ of forecasting. In this econometric method — If I recall economist Bibek Debroy introduced this term – one stares at the ceiling say for five to 10 minutes and then proclaims the forecast growth rate.

Given the dismal scenario of industry and agriculture growth rate, combined with sluggishness in the service sector this forecast seems to be of ‘celing method’.

If we consider GDP at constant market prices (at 2004-05 prices) it is expected to be 3.3 per cent only in 2012-13 compared to 6.3 per cent in 2011-12.

One thing is sure that all important parameters of the economy show secular decline in the last five years of the Congress-led UPA Government. One hopes this is not the secular issue this Government wants to achieve.

The survey observes that the manufacturing sector (comprising mining and quarrying, electricity gas and water supply and construction) registered a growth rate of only 3.5 per cent and 3.1 per cent in 2011-12 and 2012-13.

Within this, growth of manufacturing sector is at even lower levels at 2.7 per cent and 1.9 per cent for these two years. Growth in Agriculture was weak at 3.6 per cent and 1.8 per cent. Service sector which was growing at double digits earlier declined to 8.2 per cent in 2011-12 and 6.6 per cent in 2012-13.

This is like a cricket commentator who suggests that the performance of the team was bad due to batting, bowling and fielding

Then the survey gets into rudali mode of explaining the reasons for the woes. Declining savings rate is an area of concern. Given the level of inflation, particularly food inflation, that people manage to save is itself good news. Domestic savings in 2011-12 was 31 per cent and 2012-13 is awaited.

One long rudali is about households investing in gold. Government may treat it as consumption but households consider it as investment. The survey itself points out that the return on gold is 24 per cent between 2007 and 2012 and seven per cent on Nifty and eight per cent on savings deposits. The survey fails to recognise that gold jewellery is a pension/insurance product to a large number of poor women and it is also used as collateral in small business borrowings from ‘unorganised credit’ markets.

The survey recognises the importance of service sector in terms of share in GDP and growth rate but fails to point out that substantial portion of service sector activities are undertaken by partnership/proprietorship firms (unincorporated enterprises or non-corporate sector).

In many service activities like trade/hotels and restaurants/non-railway transport, etc, the share of non-corporate sector is as high as 70 per cent to 80 per cent. If the credit needs of these sectors are choked due to non-bank regulations and no reforms in regulating them then the growth rate will be impacted.

As far as Government finances are considered, less said the better. Gross tax revenue was budgeted at Rs 10.8 lakh crore for 2012-13. The April-December picture was 63 per cent of budgeted revenue (BE) which is much lower than last five years average of 69 per cent. The tax to GDP ratio has fallen to 9.9 per cent in 2011-12 compared to 11.9 per cent in 2007-08. The survey correctly identifies that raising tax to GDP ratio above 11per cent is critical for sustaining the process of fiscal consolidation. This is home work for the next Government.

The fiscal deficit of the centre is 5.7 per cent of GDP in 2011-12 as per the provisional actual. The Government of India can alone explain the terminologies like provisional actual. But if we add the deficit of State Governments and all public sector undertakings then the actual deficit of the Government system may be nearer to 12-14 per cent.

The survey identifies the weak areas and shortfalls but makes only passing references to leakages in NREGA and other such schemes. Survey should have discussed in more detail the issues associated with ‘freebies’ like NREGA and the impact of it in generating genuine productive employment. Instead it only points out about money expended and how wages have gone up. But what about generating productive assets?

The survey mentions about inflation which is running more than double digits — the retail one and more particularly the food items. But unfortunately the survey does not provide estimate of corruption percentage in relation to GDP. One can safely surmise it to be 10 per cent on the lower side since every human endeavour is impacted by that. We can call it a womb to tomb – birth certificate to death certificate – issue and so a 10 per cent assumption may be on the conservative side.

This means inflation rate plus bribe rate at 20 per cent which we call the misery rate is the single largest achievement of this UPA 2




  1. Kishore · · Reply

    ‘ceilings method’ of forecasting – one stares at the ceiling say for five to 10 minutes and then proclaims the forecast growth rate; this is really hilarious!!

    I would go further and say that the whole concept of GDP is farcical!
    -> If I wash my own back and someone else washes his own back, then GDP is constant; but if I wash someone else’s back and someone else washes my back for a fee (even paying and receiving from each other the same amount), then GDP increases!!

    NREGA – based on my own experience, have watched how NREGA is decimating whatever is left of Indian agriculture (by creating artifical minimum wage and simultaneously declining agricultural productivity by diverting agricultural labor into useless other work) and am not sure if governments can do anything further to damage agriculture more; but, caution, as always, because governments have a way of surprising every time!!
    (price and product controls, especially if they are together, are the best way to destroy a market and governments have implemented both in agriculture – the land ceiling acts (basically equivalent to a product control) and now the price control in the form of NREGA)

    but, the citizen, the farmer, as always tries to survive (inspite of the government)

  2. Prabhakar · · Reply

    The celing method is path dependent that needs factual data based on strict adherence to implementation of policy. we do not have wage policy. Without improving wealth creating activities like manufacturing, agriculture and services, and without linking wages with perforamance,during the recession time all over th world, the 6th Pay Scales for orgnized sectors generously offered thre fold increas in wages rsulting into enhancing aspirations of employees in organized sector and subsequent inflation. The work force in the organized sector constitutes a very small part of total work-force (5-10%) in India and such a work force is working in non-roductive activities, no contribution to wealth creation but

    enhancing the overheads. Similarly, a very few policies are implemented to the spirit, most

    of the funding is drained. If such is the situation, how India is going to be economic power?

  3. Economic Survey is definitely revealing but not rewarding as it has missed the opportunity to develop a road map for recovery.

  4. In case the administration does not designate a specific area where
    you can buy bunk bed from. Thus, those children who suffer from physical weaknesses, especially around the joints and
    corners of the box frame. Generally, futon bunk bed are also used by most
    college dormitories which can also be embellished with matching
    desk, dresser, armoire, desk, or other house hold accessories in these drawers.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: